Saturday, 21 November 2026

Emma's Review: A New Dawn for the Irish Daughter by Kate Hewitt

Reviewed by Emma Crowley

San Francisco, 1904: For ten years, Maggie and her husband, Brendan, have lived together happily with their adopted daughter, their only cause for pain a longing for a baby of their own. But when Brendan’s success means they can move to a more prestigious neighborhood, she feels utterly lost. With her newfound wealth, can Maggie find a way to stay true to her roots?

When Maggie unexpectedly runs into an old friend, Jenny, whose life she saved over a decade ago in this very city, she is delighted when she suggests they open a free clinic for the poorest in need of medical care. At last, Maggie feels she has a true sense of purpose.

But when Maggie tells Brendan her plans, she is heartbroken by his reaction. He wants her to enjoy their new status, rather than return to the hardships that defined their first years together. Devastated that their values are now so different, can they find their way back to one another and the life they once dreamed of?

In the midst of their own earth-shattering uncertainties, disaster strikes the city. When a huge earthquake reduces everything to dust, can Maggie find those she loves amid the chaos? And if her worst fears come true, and Brendan doesn’t appear from the wreckage, will she have the strength to see another dawn?

Book Links: Kindle or Paperback

Many thanks to Bookouture via NetGalley for my copy of A New Dawn for the Irish Daughter to review and to Sharon for having my review on the blog.

When I finished book three in Kate Hewitt’s Maggie O’Halloran’s series, A New World for the Irish Daughter I felt that that was it and we would hear no more from the fabulous character Maggie and all the brilliant supporting characters. But here we are again with book four and I was certainly glad to read more of a brilliant character that has been expertly developed since book one. I feel I have been with Maggie and co every step of their tumultuous journey since they first left Ireland and I wasn’t ready to let them go. Book four A New Dawn for the Irish Daughter is set several years on from where we last left the characters in Alaska. It’s now 1904 and they are well settled in San Francisco but still there are many ongoing changes. Brendan (Maggie’s husband) has pulled himself out of the doldrums and made a real go of things with his grocery business selling basic goods to working class people and become one of the most prominent business men in the city which is expanding at a rapid rate. In his line of business there will always be a demand for what he supplies and he now feels he can enjoy the fruits of his labour. The problem is Maggie having been through so much in the previous three books has finally come to the realisation as to what she really wants from life. Sadly, as the chapters progress this seems to be very different from the direction that Brendan is powering forward with.

The trials and tribulations of the last seven years at first seem to have been put behind both Maggie and Brendan but this wouldn’t be much of a story if things from here on in were all smooth sailing. Their adopted daughter Sheetka, from a Cherokee tribe in Alaska, is thriving in her home studies with a tutor but Maggie longs for her to become more involved with girls of her own age and to be able to attend school. This is where the prejudice strand of the story starts to make itself known and as Brendan moves the family into the richest/poshest area of the city all without Maggie knowing about it. The social snobbery really makes itself known and Maggie feels completely out of her depth and that Brendan has changed without her even realising it. I thought the exploration and development of this strand of the story was excellent and bringing back Jenny from the previous book allowed for different storylines to open up and again showed how Maggie despite everything that has gone on around her still remains true to her roots.

Maggie was once desperately poor and out of luck but now Maggie and Jenny join forces alongside Maggie’s brother Danny who has now qualified as a doctor and set up a free clinic on the Barbary Coast. This is an area they know well, an area of disrepute but they are determined to do their bit and Maggie’s nursing ambitions that she once held are allowed to come to the fore once more. Again, I found this all very interesting and it showed a different side to Danny also. Through the clinic it was like they were repaying those who had been so kind and helped them through their trials and tribulations which again highlighted they never forgot where they came from. Raciscm and classism really do rear their ugly heads and its how Maggie navigates these issues alongside her differing priorities from Brendan that kept me engaged and keen to see what would next occur for Maggie. The author certainly threw her all at the character and put her through the mill.

Truthfully, I have always found Maggie to be a bit of a divisive character. Don’t get me wrong I have felt great empathy towards her throughout all she has endured, the highs, the lows, the good times and bad, the challenges and significant events that have moulded her into the woman she is today. No doubt she needed to go through all these life changing events in order to reach the position that she now emotionally and physically occupies. But still she can be such a frustrating character to read about because a lot of the time she is thinking something or worrying but takes forever to actually come out and say things that need to be said or confronted about. I suppose this is also what makes her a great character to read about and that she is someone who would get you talking in a book club discussion.
 
I found the pacing of the book to be quite slow up until around the midway point but that has been the case with all the books and then the second half things are really ramped up and it was some rollercoaster of a ride the reader was taken on. There was so much emotion. One minute I was delighted with the way things are going and then the next the author provides heartbreak and challenges that seem completely insurmountable. I really wasn’t prepared at all for those last few chapters. I hadn’t seen it coming at all. I was reading in disbelief almost reluctant to keep turning the pages. It was very brave of Kate Hewitt to take the story in the direction she did although I know lots of readers will be left thinking why did you do that? By the books end I wasn’t left in any doubt that there will be a book five. This ending felt more solid in that respect compared to book four. I can see where things will go to some degree although I am still left with a sense of oh why couldn’t have things worked out differently? 

I have been purposefully vague in details of the plot with regards to this book because to say anything would give away key plot points and ruin things for readers new to the series. But fans of the series since book one will appreciate the story although the heartbreak Maggie endures will take some getting used to. I have been seriously impressed with his series so far. It’s grown in its scope and provided me with a lot more than I had bargained from when I first began it.I love how historical events are woven throughout each book and the detailed research undertaken is clear throughout. The themes of snobbery, prejudice, courage, emotional family relationships, resilience and compassion all feature heavily throughout with a female character who grows stronger with time. This is definitely a book that I would recommend, and I am eagerly awaiting the next instalment, A New Life for the Irish Daughter which will be published next April.

No comments:

Post a Comment